Friday, September 07, 2012

How to choose a Cloud Provider

The wonderful site, allows you to run tests on latency, small and large file download speed. Depending on the nature of your application, the choice of a provider is crucial (of course price is another important factor).

In the tests, Large File Download category, Amazon S3 is the winner with an average of 15.33 Mb/s. This might be suitable for applications working with large files (pdfs, catalogs, repositories).

Windows Azure Service is the winner of the small file category with around 2.5 Mb/s. The difference between the large and small file is significant. This order of magnitude difference is probably due to the overhead of authentication, establishing a connection etc. Once the pipe is secure and ready, you are probably bound to the limitations of your IPO as well as the cloud service provider's SLA.

Latency might be a concern for high throughput applications - I would argue that self-hosting or keeping the applications close behind the scenes might be a better choice than putting a cloud between your data and application. If it is not avoidable, though, Amazon S3 seems to be offering the best (minimum) latency. This (and the file download times) is impacted by the Geographical designation of the applications and their clients. Clearly as the audience grows, one might want to implement load balancing facilities to route users to the closest cloud servers (S3 offers service in CA and VA for instance)

Great tool Cloud Harmony!!

Large File Download Tests

ServiceLocationTime (secs)# of SamplesTransferred (MB)Min Mb/sMax Mb/sStd DevMedian Mb/sAvg Mb/s
Simple Storage Service (S3)VA, US10.39419.9913.1817.7113.06%16.1315.33
Nirvanix SDNTest Failed
HP Cloud Object StorageAZ, US8.1242.491.773.1724.64%2.562.42
Windows Azure StorageTX, US10.1849.636.118.1712.71%8.067.5
Internap Cloud Storage6.445.353.8114.2966.31%6.067.23
Zetta Enterprise Cloud Storage7.8946.295.578.2619.6%5.916.39
Simple Storage Service (S3)CA, US8.9346.283.867.5627.44%7.396.22
Google Storage for Developers8.2411.046.7415.2737.68%12.410.56
Windows Azure StorageIL, US8.64412.589.5912.3610.65%11.6811.14

Small File Download Tests

ServiceLocationTime (secs)# of SamplesTransferred (MB)Min Mb/sMax Mb/sStd DevMedian Mb/sAvg Mb/s
HP Cloud Object StorageAZ, US5.9190.690.511.4741.31%0.850.97
Google Storage for Developers5.27110.740.812.7442.41%1.231.28
Internap Cloud Storage6.55100.60.431.0831.46%0.880.79
Simple Storage Service (S3)VA, US7.28130.690.672.7137.89%1.771.64
Windows Azure StorageIL, US3.38130.811.174.2344.77%2.612.52
Zetta Enterprise Cloud Storage4.62110.790.72.5341.96%1.451.62
Nirvanix SDNTest Failed
Simple Storage Service (S3)CA, US6.47100.570.291.3156.2%0.590.75
Windows Azure StorageTX, US4.91110.730.832.3637.67%1.151.39

Network Latency Tests

ServiceLocationTime (secs)# of SamplesMin msMax msStd DevMedian msAvg ms
HP Cloud Object StorageAZ, US0.65981000.85%9998.8
Simple Storage Service (S3)VA, US0.43741506.49%4444.86
Simple Storage Service (S3)CA, US0.751091213.86%117116
Windows Azure StorageIL, US0.46648577.64%5051.5
Nirvanix SDNTest Failed
Internap Cloud Storage0.7549118038.83%92113.75
Windows Azure StorageTX, US0.53570731.6%7171.4
Google Storage for Developers0.61652573.98%5454.33
Zetta Enterprise Cloud Storage0.48490910.55%9190.75

No comments: